General Management @ Knowledge Zone



Should Companies Jointly Venture

by Sauvik Banerjee
MBA (International Business),
Leeds University Business School,
Asso. Manager, PwC Leeds.

Previous

Part - II

MAJOR WRITE DOWNS DUE TO M&A FAILURES *

   M&A    Write Downs ($Billion)
   AOL/ Time Warner    ($ 99.50)
   Down Jones/ Telerate    ($ 1.00)
   Eli Lilly/ PCS Health Systems    ($ 2.40)
   JDS Uniphase Various (M&A)    ($ 56.10)
   Lucent Various (M&A)    ($ 16.20)
   NTL Various (M&A)    ($ 14.20)
   Sony/ Columbia    ($ 2.70)
   World Com (Various M&A)    ($ 45.00)

MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS-KEY FINDINGS

A survey by PwC** has shown that the three main reasons, which drive executives to do M&A's, are access to new products, growth in market share and access to new markets. The objectives for M&A's mentioned in the survey are never in doubt, but the process used is, as the findings below explain further.

Leslie Norton (1998) in a study conducted for Barron's, states that between 60-80% of M&A's are financial failures while a study of 118 companies by KPMG in 2001 found that 70% of M&A's do not created shareholder value for the merged companies. A study by Mckinsey&Co of 160 acquisitions across 11 sectors revealed that 42% had lower growth rates after acquisition when compared to their industry peers, 88% failed to accelerate growth and 60% failed to earn returns that would cover their annual cost of capital required to do the acquisition, while a Business week analysis of 302 M&A's showed that 61% of the merged companies destroyed share holder value.

Next


* Source: Pekar P. Jr. in the 2003 Strategic Alliance Conference (New York).
** Ivey Business Journal May/June 2003.